Get Permission Mishra, Mohapatra, Nial, and Mohanty: Lichen planus pigmentosus (LPP) versus erythema dyschromicum perstans (ashy’s dermatosis): A diagnostic dilemma!- Letter to editor

Lichen planus pigmentosus (LPP) is a rare variant of lichen planus that was first reported in India by Bhutani et al. in the year 1974.1 He later renamed the term giving a distinct nomenclature to it. Commonly it has an actinic pattern of distribution that begins with appearance of brown to gray pigmented macules with ill-defined borders, initially over pre-auricular areas and forehead, which later coalesce to form hyperpigmented patches, occurring in darker skin individuals.2 It occurs in middle aged individuals with few studies showing a greater incidence in females.3 It has an insidious onset and is characterized by persistent, asymptomatic or mildly pruritic slate gray pigmentation predominantly over the face and neck (Figure 1) followed by upper extremities and trunk. Commonly a diffuse pattern of pigmentation is encountered, while reticular, blotchy and perifollicular patterns have also been described.2 The patches are mostly symmetrical in distribution although various other patterns such as linear,4 segmental,5 zosteriform6 and blashkoid7 have being reported in various literature. The oral mucosa may rarely be involved and there is sparing of palms, soles and nails.8 Another important variant of LPP which is rare and needs a special mention is LPP inversus that was reported by Pock et al. in the year 2001,9 occurring commonly in photoprotected areas, mostly the flexures and intertriginous areas. Unlike Lichen planus, in LPP there is no or occasional pruritus and Wickham’s striae is absent.2 Cases of LPP have been reported from various parts of the country India as well as seen in Japan, Korea, Middle East and Latin America.

Figure 1

Clinical Pic of patient (LPP)- Showing ill-deffined, discrete and confluent areas of slate gray pigmentation distributed over face and neck

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/608019d6-cef1-49fa-8d16-679c96223821/image/c9de3a56-5e61-410e-8ac2-063e56cca85a-uimage.png

Figure 2

A): Scanner view 40x; B, C): Low power view 100x; Shows Epidermis is atrophic with basket weave hyperkeratosis and dermis showing a minimal superficial perivascular lymphohistiocytic infiltrate and focal basal vacuolar degeneration with marked melanin incontinence (burnt out inflammation)- Histopathological findings in Lichen planus pigmentosus

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/608019d6-cef1-49fa-8d16-679c96223821/image/1cc47ad1-b090-4c2b-bc21-4d67ba2ca123-uimage.png

Although the etiological factors of LPP still remains a debatable issue, a number of agents have been reported to act as predisposing factors. Its occurrence in photo exposed areas has pointed towards the possibility of sunlight as an etiologic agent.10 Other possible inciting agents include topical mustard oil containing allyl isothyocynate and amla oil, a potential photosensitizer.11 LPP is also thought to be a type IV hypersensitivity reaction to some unknown antigen with lichenoid reaction at dermoepidermal junction leading to melanin incontinence and superficial dermal pigmentation. T lymphocyte dysfunction have also been postulated in its etiopathogenesis.2

Histologically LPP shows varied histological features depending on the age of the lesion, with early lesions showing marked inflammation at the interface and older lesions showing less inflammation and prominent dermal pigmentation.11 The findings include atrophic epidermis with apoptosis of keratinocytes, basal layer vacuolar degeneration and dermal pigment incontinence.3 The inflammatory phase is characterized by dense lichenoid (lymphohistiocytic) infiltrates with prominent basal cell vacuolar degeneration and some pigment incontinence. The second pattern (burnt out inflammation) shows upper dermal perivascular lymphohistiocytic infiltrate and minimal to absent basal cell vacuolar degeneration with significant pigment incontinence3 (Figure 2). Similar to Lichen planus, colloid bodies can be seen in LPP as well.3 The infiltrate is composed of CD8 T-lymphocytes predominantly.3 Immune deposits are more commonly seen in LP in comparison to LPP where it is seen in only 15% of cases. Occassionally DIF maybe positive with IgM, IgG, C3 and fibrinogen deposits in colloid bodies or basement membrane zone.2, 3

The closest differential diagnosis posing a diagnostic challenge for a dermatologist is Erythema dyschromicum perstans (EDP) or Ashy’s dermatosis. It differs from LPP by extensive involvement over sunexposed as well as covered areas, greyish blue to brownish macules with erythematous, elevated borders in early inflammatory stages.12 Histologically EDP shows basal cell vacuolar degeneration with dermal mononuclear infiltrate that is periadnexal in location and dermal pigment (melanin) deposition is in deeper dermis compared to superficial dermal deposition in LPP. Second closest differential is pigmented contact dermatitis / Riehl’s melanosis, which has similar features as that of LPP both clinically and histopathologically. Clinically its characterized by hyperpigmentation of face and neck due to ingredients in cosmetic products.13 Histological features causing a diagnostic overlap with LPP includes interface dermatitis, lichenoid infiltrates and melanin incontinence.3 A definitive diagnosis however is established only after positive patch test identifying the allergen and by eliciting an adequate history of prior application of topical agents such as cosmetics and dyes.3 Other differentials include drug induced pigmentation, post inflammatory pigmentation, macular amyloidosis, frictional melanosis and idiopathic eruptive macular pigmentation.3

LPP has been reported in various literatures to be associated with disorders like scarring alopecia and circulating antinuclear antibodies,14 frontal fibrosing alopecia 15, acrokeratosis of Bazex and head and neck carcinoma (paraneoplastic LPP),16 hepatitis C infection17 and nephrotic syndrome.18

The natural course of disease in LPP is variable with some cases showing spontaneous resolution while certain cases are refractory to treatment with persistence of pigmentation over years. Review of literature have suggested various treatment modalities for LPP. Use of vit A was recommended by Bhutani et al. 19 while Al Mutairi and El Khalawany found tacrolimus ointment to be effective in 53.8% of patients. 20 The use of oral dapsone along with topical tacrolimus may halt the progression of pigmentation as suggested by Sehgal et al. 9 Few cases also responded well low fluence Q switched Nd-YAG laser.21 An open label, non-randomized, prospective study by Muthu et al. showed improvement with oral isotretinoin at a dose of 20mg/day for 6 months.22 Other treatment modalities include photoprotection, oral tranexamic acid (250mg/day for 4-6 months), topical and oral steroids, topical 5% azelaic acid, oral acitretin (25mg) and Narrow band ultraviolet B phototherapy.23 The response rates showed moderate to good improvement in most of the studies.23 The limitations of the studies include their small sample size, low levels of evidence and absence of specific assessment tools for evaluation of treatment outcomes.23 In EDP, again topical tacrolimus and narrow band ultraviolet light have shown promising results whereas oral isotretinoin and dapsone showed recurrence and lasers have shown to be ineffective.24 A case series by Aisleen et al. have reported resolution of lesions of EDP with a combination therapy of oral prednisolone and isotretinoin if initiated at early stage of the disease.25 Availability of few studies and case series as well as lack of randomized clinical trials have accounted to absence of any standard therapeutic modality in its treatment.25

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

LK Bhutani TR Bedi RK Pandhi NC Nayak Lichen planus pigmentosusDermatologica197414914350

2 

AJ Kanwar S Dogra S Handa D Parsad BD Radotra A study of 124 Indian patients with lichen planus pigmentosusClin Exp Dermatol20032854815

3 

I Mathews DM Thappa N Singh D Gochhait Lichen planus pigmentosus A short reviewPihment Int20163510

4 

S Hong JH Shin HY Kang Two cases of lichen planus pigmentosus presenting with a linear patternJ Korean Med Sci20041911524

5 

YH Kumar AR Babu Segmental lichen planus pigmentosus: An unusual presentationIndian Dermatol Online J2014521579

6 

S Cho KK Whang Lichen planus pigmentosus presenting in zosteriform patternJ Dermatol19972431937

7 

S Akarsu T Ilknur E Özer E Fetil Lichen planus pigmentosus distributed along the lines of BlaschkoInt J Dermatol20135222534

8 

A Ghosh A Coondoo Lichen planus Pigmentosus: The controversial consencusIndian J Dermatol20166154826

9 

L Pock L Jelínková L Drlík S Abrhámová S Vojtechovská D Sezemská Lichen planus pigmentosus-inversusJ Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol20011554524

10 

E Rieder J Kaplan H Kamino M Sanchez MK Pomeranz Lichen planus pigmentosusDermatol Online J2013191220713

11 

VN Sehgal P Verma SN Bhattacharya S Sharma F Rasool Lichen planus pigmentosusSkinmed201311296103

12 

T Numata K Harada R Tsuboi Y Mitsuhashi Erythema Dyschromicim Perstans: Identical to Ashy Dermatosis or not?Case Rep Dermatol20157214650

13 

T Tienthavorn P Tresukosol P Sudtikoonaseth Patch testing and histopathology in Thai patients with hyperpigmentation due to erythema dyschromicum perstans, lichen planus pigmentosus, and pigmented contact dermatitisAsian Pac J Allergy Immunol201432218592

14 

G Parodi A Parodi M Guarrera G Cannata G Piccardo Lichen pigmentosus with scarring alopecia and circulating antinuclear antibodiesInt J Dermatol19902932278

15 

NC Dlova Frontal fibrosing alopecia and lichen planus pigmentosus: Is there a link?Br J Dermatol201316843942

16 

B Sassolas A Zagnoli J P Leroy G Guillet Lichen planus pigmentosus associated with acrokeratosis of BazexClin Exp Dermatol1994191703

17 

V Vachiramon P Suchonwanit K Thadanipon Bilateral linear Lichen planus pigmentosus associated with hepatitis C virus infectionCase Rep Dermatol20102316972

18 

G Mancuso RM Berdondini Coexistence of lichen planus pigmentosus and minimal change nephrotic syndromeEur J Dermatol200919438990

19 

LK Bhutani M George SM Bhate Vitamin A in the treatment of lichen planus pigmentosusBr J Dermatol197910044734

20 

N Al-Mutairi M El-Khalawany Clinicopathological characteristics of lichen planus pigmentosus and its response to tacrolimus ointment: An open label, non-randomized, prospective studyJ EurAcad Dermatol Venereol20102453540

21 

XD Han CL Goh A case of lichen planus pigmentosus that was recalcitrant to topical treatment responding to pigment laser treatmentDermatol Ther20142752647

22 

SK Muthu T Narang UN Saikia AJ Kanwar D Parsad S Dogra Low-dose oral isotretinoin therapy in lichen planus pigmentosus: an open-label, non-randomized prospective pilot studyInt J Dermatol2016559104854

23 

N Syder K Sicco D Gutierrez Updates In Therapeutics for Lichen Planus PigmentosusJ Drugs Dermatol202221332430

24 

N Leung M Oliveira MA Selim L Mckinley-Grant E Lesesky Erythema dyschromicum perstans: A case report and systematic review of histologic presentation and treatmentInt J Dermatol201827421622

25 

A Diaz R Gillihan K Motaparthi A Rees Combination therapy with prednisone and isotretinoin in early erythema dyschromicum perstans: A retrospective seriesJAAD Case Rep20206320713



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 13-06-2023

Accepted : 19-08-2023


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijpo.2023.074


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 754

PDF Downloaded: 141