Get Permission Gupta, Bhardwaj, and Sharma: Cytological grading of lymphocytic thyroiditis and its correlation with thyroid hormonal status


Introduction

Thyroid diseases are among the commonest endocrine disorders worldwide with about 42 million people in India suffering from them.1 Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is the first line diagnostic procedure for evaluating thyroid lesions and can effectively distinguish between neoplastic and non‑neoplastic lesions.2 Most thyroid nodules are benign and a benign result is the most common FNA interpretation (approximately 60-70% of all cases).3

Chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis is the second most common benign thyroid FNA diagnosis next to benign follicular nodule,2, 4 and also overall the second most common thyroid lesion diagnosed on FNAC after goitre.5 Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (HT), a synonym for chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis or autoimmune thyroiditis is more common in women and has prevalence rate of 1–4% and incidence of 30–60/100000 population per year.5 FNA is highly sensitive in diagnosing HT, with a diagnostic accuracy rate of 92%.6 Most patients present with painless enlargement of thyroid, usually symmetric and diffuse. It is the most common cause of hypothyroidism in iodine sufficient areas of the world.7 Besides FNAC, clinical features, thyroid antibody titres, thyroid hormonal profile, and ultrasonography also help in its diagnosis.6, 8

The present study was carried out to evaluate thyroid fine needle aspirates for cytological features of lymphocytic thyroiditis; to grade lymphocytic thyroiditis cases based on predefined cytological criteria and to correlate cytological grades with thyroid hormonal status.

Materials and Methods

It was a three year retrospective study conducted in the Department of Pathology, Government Medical College, Jammu. Thyroid fine needle aspirates from patients presenting with thyroid swelling during this period were retrieved from the archives of our department. May-Grunwald-Giemsa (MGG) and Papanicolaou (PAP) stained smears from these patients were examined under light microscopy.

Cytomorphological features were assessed as per Bethesda system and the cases that were composed of many polymorphic lymphoid cells associated with benign thyroid follicular cells and/or Hurthle cells were reported as lymphocytic thyroiditis (LT) as per The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology. A minimum number of follicular or Hurthle cells for adequacy were not required for diagnosis of lymphocytic thyroiditis.3

These cases were further graded based on predefined cytological criteria as per Bhatia et al.8 as:

  1. Grade 0- No lymphoid cells.

  2. Grade I (Mild)- Few lymphoid cells infiltrating the follicles/increased number of lymphocytes in the background.

  3. Grade II (Moderate)- Moderate lymphocytic infiltration or mild lymphocytic infiltration with Hurthle cell change/giant cells/anisonucleosis.

  4. Grade III (Severe)- Florid lymphocytic inflammation with germinal center formation, very few follicular cells left.

Thyroid hormonal profile of these patients, wherever available, was evaluated. The patients were classified as euthyroid, hypothyroid and hyperthyroid based on their serum TSH, T4 and T3 values. Cytological grades were compared with thyroid hormonal status wherever available. Statistically, the association of grades with hormonal status was assessed using Fischer Exact test of significance and P value < 0.05 was considered as statistically significant.

Results

A total of 162 cases of lymphocytic thyroiditis were reported as per Bethesda system in our study. Most patients were in 31-40 years (48; 29.63%) age group followed by 21-30 years (36; 22.22%) and 41-50 years (32; 19.75%) age groups. Mean age was 35.99 years with age ranging from 7 to 80 years. The study had 146 (90.12%) females and 16 (9.88%) males with female to male ratio of 9.125.

These cases were further graded as per Bhatia et al criteria. Maximum number of cases were of grade II thyroiditis followed by grade I and grade III (Table 1) (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3).

Table 1

Distribution of lymphocytic thyroiditis cases into cytological grades

Lymphocytic thyroiditis - cytological grading No. of cases Percentage
Grade I (Mild) 48 29.6%
Grade II (Moderate) 104 64.2%
Grade III (Severe) 10 6.2%
Total 162 100%

Out of 162 cases, thyroid hormonal profile was available for 78 cases. Maximum patients were hypothyroid (42; 53.85%) followed by euthyroid (21; 26.92%) and hyperthyroid (15; 19.23%). Cases with elevated TSH but normal T4 and T3 were considered as having subclinical hypothyroidism (11; 14.10%).

Cytological grades were compared with thyroid hormonal status as shown in Table 2. Majority of patients with grade II thyroiditis were associated with hypothyroidism. Most of the euthyroid cases were associated with grade II thyroiditis followed by grade I thyroiditis and none with grade III thyroiditis. No patient with grade III thyroiditis with available thyroid profile had normal hormonal status. The lymphocytic thyroiditis cases with hyperthyroidism (Hashitoxicosis), most were having grade II (8 cases) followed by grade I (6 cases) thyroiditis with only 1 case with grade III thyroiditis (Table 2). However, the correlation between cytological grades and thyroid hormonal status of the patients was not statistically significant (P value = 0.21 i.e. > 0.05).

Table 2

Comparison of cytological grades with thyroid hormonal status

Cytological grade Euthyroid Hypothyroid Hyperthyroid Total
Grade I 8 8 6 22
Grade II 13 32 8 53
Grade III 0 2 1 3
Total 21 42 15 78

Figure 1

Photomicrograph from a case of grade I lymphocytic thyroiditis showing a cluster of thyroid follicular cells infiltrated by few lymphocytes (MGG 400X).

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/f3d2732c-c768-44f6-8479-4c4b83c5fb3d/image/dce7d1d1-8138-4373-aca3-1d9fef4c630a-uimage.png

Figure 2

Photomicrograph from a case of grade II lymphocytic thyroiditis showing mild lymphocytic infiltration with Hurthle cell change, anisonucleosis and increased lymphocytes in the background (MGG 400X).

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/f3d2732c-c768-44f6-8479-4c4b83c5fb3d/image/769b514a-5745-47a5-a435-1d18ca010e85-uimage.png

Figure 3

Photomicrograph from a case of grade III lymphocytic thyroiditis showing florid inflammation comprising of polymorphic lymphoid cells, and few scattered follicular cells (MGG 400X).

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/0914d50a-36d5-4792-916d-7391e4fb0fe9image3.jpeg

Discussion

The first report of chronic thyroiditis, struma lymphomatosa was described by Hakaru Hashimoto in 1912, which bears his name.8 Hashimoto's thyroiditis is an autoimmune disease that results in destruction of thyroid gland and gradual and progressive thyroid failure.7 The incidence of HT seems to be increasing in the recent times. It has become 10 times more common than it was until the early 1990s. This increase in incidence has been linked to excess iodine intake, particularly in coastal areas.9, 10

Cytological findings of lymphoid cells in the background and infiltration of follicular cells by lymphoid cells are characteristic. Variable features include Hurthle cells, plasma cells, epithelioid cell granulomas and multinucleated giant cells.11 In the usual case hypothyroidism develops gradually. In some patients, it may be preceded by transient thyrotoxicosis during which free T4 and T3 levels are elevated and TSH is diminished. As hypothyroidism supervenes, T4 and T3 levels fall with a compensatory increase in TSH.7

Thyroid fine needle aspirates were analysed for cytological features of lymphocytic thyroiditis according to Bethesda system and a total of 162 cases were reported as lymphocytic thyroiditis in the present study. Most common age group of these patients in our study was 31-40 years which is similar to studies by Bhatia et al,8 Anila et al,6 and Shetty et al.12 This younger age of diagnosis of lymphocytic thyroiditis in Indian population as shown by these Indian studies differs from a western study in which median age of subjects was 58 years.13 The present study showed female predominance that is comparable to most studies in literature.5, 6, 8, 12

On further grading, majority patients had grade II thyroiditis followed by grade I thyroiditis with grade III thyroiditis in least number of patients in our study. This is similar to studies by Bhatia et al.8 and Shetty et al.12 However, in a study by Anila et al,6 majority of patients had grade I thyroiditis and in a study by Sood et al.,5 majority cases were of grade III thyroiditis.

On assessing thyroid hormonal status, majority of the patients were hypothyroid similar to many other studies.8, 12, 14 Patients with subclinical hypothyroidism in our study were 11 (14.10%). In a study by Shetty et al.,12 39.6% of the cases presented with subclinical hypothyroidism which is higher than our study. On further correlation of cytological grades with thyroid hormonal status of patients, no statistically significant association was found in our study which is consistent with many studies in literature.6, 8, 12

However, in a study by Sood et al.,5 Grade 3 lymphocytic infiltration has statistical correlation with TPO and TSH together or TSH alone. In a study by Kumar et al.,15 the association between hormonal status and lymphocytic infiltration was statistically significant (P- 0.02). Among cases with moderate to heavy infiltration, the ratio of hypothyroidism (44%) was greater than hyperthyroidism (6%), but no statistically significant association was noted for hypo- or euthyroidism (P- 0.36; P- 0.29). Among cases with minimal infiltration the proportion of hyperthyroid cases was greatest (47%) and statistically significant (P- 0.0006). In a study by Megalamane et al.,16 there was a statistical significance between the cytological grades of LT and TSH (p-value <0.001).

There is an overlap of clinical, radiological and hormonal parameters in Hashimoto's thyroiditis and other thyroid lesions, and thus are not very helpful.15 In equivocal cases antibody testing is helpful, but about 7 to 33% cases of Hashimoto's thyroiditis are antibody negative particularly in initial phase of the disease due to local antibody production by intrathyroidal lymphocytes without spill over into the blood.11, 16 FNAC is thus considered superior as well as more cost-effective than antibody screening to diagnose Hashimoto's thyroiditis,10, 17 in initial stage of disease and if antibody testing facilities are not available as in our institution or are not affordable due to high cost.15

However, FNAC has certain pitfalls in diagnosing lymphocytic thyroiditis. Diagnosis of Hashimoto's thyroiditis is likely to be missed in smears showing cytological evidence of hyperplasia as in Grave's disease or abundant colloid.9 Distinction between Hashimoto's thyroiditis in toxic phase i.e. Hashitoxicosis and pure Grave’s disease may not be possible cytologically and require correlation with clinical details and hormonal profile.11 Smears showing hyperplastic follicular cells, Hurthle cells, a limited population of lymphocytes in the background but absence of lymphocytes in epithelial groups poses a major diagnostic problem, with adenomatous/colloid/hyperplastic goitre as the main differential diagnosis in I2 deficient regions.15

In early stages of Hashimoto thyroiditis, selective sampling from hyperplastic nodule comprising predominantly of Hurthle cells with sparse or absent lymphocytic infiltrate raises the suspicion of Hurthle cell neoplasm.3 Hurthle cells in flat sheets favor thyroiditis while poorly organized, and poorly cohesive cell clusters favor neoplasia.11 Predominance of lymphoid component as in grade III thyroiditis may raise the possibility of lymphoma.12 About 75% of primary lymphomas of thyroid gland arise in a background of Hashimoto's thyroiditis.11 The polymorphic lymphoid population helps in distinguishing these cases from Non-Hodgkin lymphoma.3, 8 Immunophenotyping studies are essential to confirm its diagnosis in morphologically equivocal cases. The incidence of malignancy in HT is documented to vary from 0.4% to 28%. The follicular or Hurthle cells in LT occasionally show mild atypia, nuclear enlargement, grooves and chromatin clearing, therefore possibility of papillary carcinoma should be slightly raised.3, 12

Thus, being aware of overlapping cytological features with other thyroid pathologies, and by following an integrated approach with clinicopathologic correlation, some of the potential pitfalls and uncertainties can be minimized and the value of FNAC in the diagnosis of lymphocytic thyroiditis can be enhanced.

Conclusion

Though a combination of cytomorphology, clinical features, thyroid hormonal profile, antibody testing and ultrasonographic features help in the diagnosis of lymphocytic thyroiditis particularly in cytologically equivocal cases, FNAC remains the "gold standard" investigation for diagnosis of lymphocytic thyroiditis similar to other studies.5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14 However, the cytological grades show no statistically significant correlation with thyroid hormonal status in our study.

Source of Funding

Nil.

Conflict of Interest

None declared.

References

1 

AmbikaGopalakrishnan Unnikrishnan UshaV Menon Thyroid disorders in India: An epidemiological perspectiveIndian J Endocr Metab201115678812230-8210Medknow

2 

Santosh Kumar Mondal Simanti Sinha Bijan Basak Dipanwita Nag Roy Swapan Kumar Sinha The Bethesda system for reporting thyroid fine needle aspirates: A cytologic study with histologic follow-upJ Cytol20133029490970-9371Medknow

3 

S Z Ali E S Cibas The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology. Definitions, Criteria and Explanatory Notes2nd edSpringerSwitzerland2018

4 

Payal Mehra Anand Kumar Verma Thyroid Cytopathology Reporting by the Bethesda System: A Two-Year Prospective Study in an Academic InstitutionPathol Res Int20152090-8091, 2042-003X10.1155/2015/240505Hindawi Limited

5 

Neelam Sood Jitendra Singh Nigam Correlation of Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology Findings with Thyroid Function Test in Cases of Lymphocytic ThyroiditisJ Thyroid Res20142090-8067, 2042-007210.1155/2014/430510Hindawi Limited

6 

KR Anila Nileena Nayak K Jayasree Cytomorphologic spectrum of lymphocytic thyroiditis and correlation between cytological grading and biochemical parametersJ Cytol201633314590970-9371Medknow

7 

A Maitra V Kumar A K Abbas J C Aster The endocrine systemRobbins and Cotran Pathologic Basis of DiseaseIIReed Elsevier India Private Limited2014108589

8 

Alka Bhatia Arvind Rajwanshi Radharaman J Dash Bhagwant R Mittal Akshay K Saxena Lymphocytic thyroiditis – is cytological grading significant? A correlation of grades with clinical, biochemical, ultrasonographic and radionuclide parametersCyto J20074100974-596310.1186/1742-6413-4-10Scientific Scholar

9 

B N Gayathri M L Harendra Kumar R Kalyani Prasad K Krishna Fine needle aspiration cytology of Hashimoto′s thyroiditis - A diagnostic pitfall with review of literatureJ Cytol201128421030970-9371Medknow

10 

Faiyaz Ahmad Ashutosh Kumar Jyotsana Khatri Ankita Mittal Seema Awasthi Shyamoli Dutta Cytological Diagnosis of Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis Revealing the Increased Frequency than Expected: A Retrospective Study of 750 Thyroid AspiratesInt J Med Res Professionals20162314362454-6356, 2454-6364Marwah Infotech

11 

S R Orell G F Sterrett Orell & Sterrett's Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology5th edRELX India Private LimitedNew Delhi201211855

12 

Vijaya Chowdappa Archana Shetty Cytomorphological spectrum of Hashimoto's thyroiditis and its correlation with hormonal profile and hematological parametersJ Cytol2019363137410970-9371Medknow

13 

M. P. J. Vanderpump W. M. G. Tunbrldge J. M. French D. Appleton D. Bates F. Clark The incidence of thyroid disorders in the community: a twenty-year follow-up of the Whickham SurveyClin Endocrinol199543155680300-0664, 1365-2265Wiley

14 

Shirish S. Chandanwale Rahul Nair Anushree Gambhir Supreet Kaur Aditi Pandey Abhinav Shetty Cytomorphological Spectrum of Thyroiditis: A Review of 110 CasesJ Thyroid Res20182090-8067, 2042-007210.1155/2018/5246516Hindawi Limited

15 

N Kumar C Ray S Jain Aspiration cytology of Hashimoto's thyroiditis in an endemic areaCytopathol20021313190956-5507, 1365-2303Wiley

16 

Supreetha Megalamane Hemalatha Anantharamaiah Shashidhar Nagaraj Kurpad Correlation of Cytological Grading in Lymphocytic Thyroiditis with Thyroid Hormones and Antibodies - A Retrospective Study in the Era of Bethesda System of Thyroid ReportingJ Clin Diagn Res20181281042249-782XJCDR Research and Publications

17 

C P Madhu V Swetha Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology of Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis: Its Diagnostic LimitationIJSS J Surg201731279



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijpo.2020.074


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 3677

PDF Downloaded: 912